Study Offers Systems Solutions to Gender Gap
Existing gender gaps in academic medicine may have a negative impact on workplace culture and organizational effectiveness but there are simple, systems-based solutions, suggests a new study by Department of Medicine faculty.
The study was led by Professors Reena Pattani and Sharon Straus and published in BMC Medicine on April 9. It analyzed interviews conducted with female and male faculty members at the University of Toronto and six affiliated hospitals, and uncovered the negative impact of the gender gap in academic medicine.
“We identified three key themes that the gender gap fuels: social exclusion of female colleagues, reinforced stereotypes, and unprofessional behaviour,” said Straus, who is Vice Chair of Mentorship, Equity and Diversity at the Department of Medicine and Director of the Knowledge Translation Program at the Li Ka Shing Knowledge Institute of St. Michael’s Hospital.
“Interestingly, instead of just focusing on the issues, the study’s participants also offered system-based solutions to close the gap.”
Several opportunities to bridge the gap emerged from this research, said Straus, who is also interim physician-in-chief at St. Michael’s. The participants suggested more streamlined recruitment, hiring, and promotions processes and simple amendments to the work environment, such as unconscious bias training for leaders and holding meetings during work hours so that all faculty members can attend. Formalized mentorship and consistent monitoring of the gender gap were also offered as solutions.
“These are solutions at the level of the institution, rather than at the level of the individual,” said Pattani, an assistant professor at U of T and physician at St. Michael’s. “The advice historically given to women has been about how they can change their own personal behaviours. That overlooks some of the systemic factors holding women back. We need to ensure that institutions can create a more inclusive environment for all.”
This work, funded by the Department of Medicine, builds on previous research conducted by Dr. Straus, which found that a significant gender gap existed across the research institute at St. Michael’s Hospital. Since then, steps have been taken to reduce the gender imbalance.
Across the University of Toronto’s Department of Medicine, search guidelines, transparent promotions processes, and a formal mentorship program have also been implemented, and a biennial faculty survey helps university and hospital leadership monitor trends of the gender gap over time. At St Michael’s Hospital, the Department of Medicine has also been hosting networking opportunities for female trainees.
“These are inspiring measures to promote equity. We can work together to institute more system-based approaches like these ones, which are low cost and easy to implement,” Pattani said.
The researchers acknowledge that there are also other factors beyond gender that impact workplace culture, which were not studied in this paper. Further research is needed to understand how sexual orientation, race and ethnicity play a role in the representation gap, Straus said.